AI-generated research — verify before acting.
This scorecard was produced with the assistance of AI and may contain errors or outdated information. District policies change. Before contacting your school board or making decisions based on this data, verify the current status directly with your district.
✅ Already doing this (publicly visible)
⚠️ Partially doing this / unclear
❌ Not in place (opportunity)
The 5 Core Protections (achievable baseline)
- Public Policy – District explains how it handles ICE
- Warrant Requirement – Requires proper legal documentation before access
- Front Office Protocol – Staff know what to do if ICE shows up
- Student Privacy – Clear protection of student information
- Family Communication – Families are informed and reassured
🛡
Tier 1 — Strongest Existing Models
These districts have made the most progress. None are complete. The most common gaps are training, emergency protocols, and formal board adoption.
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ✅ |
| Warrant Requirement | ⚠️ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ✅ |
| Family Communication | ✅ |
→
Next step: Add a simple front office procedure + clarify warrant language
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ⚠️ |
| Warrant Requirement | ⚠️ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ✅ |
| Family Communication | ✅ |
→
Next step: Turn guidance into a clear, simple policy + staff protocol
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ⚠️ |
| Warrant Requirement | ✅ |
| Front Office Protocol | ⚠️ |
| Student Privacy | ✅ |
| Family Communication | ⚠️ |
→
Next step: Improve visibility + simple staff instructions
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ⚠️ |
| Warrant Requirement | ⚠️ |
| Front Office Protocol | ✅ |
| Student Privacy | ⚠️ |
| Family Communication | ⚠️ |
→
Next step: Make policies clear and public-facing
Even in the best Utah districts, gaps remain.
Tier 1 districts have made meaningful progress, but no Utah district has a complete
protective policy. Every one of them can still be pushed further — and Tier 2 and
Tier 3 districts are largely starting from scratch.
In Utah, every protection that exists is the result of local organizing. The school
board in your district can act right now.
⚠️
Tier 2 — Partial Protections
These districts typically have student privacy protections in place but lack formal policies, written protocols, or staff training. They are reachable targets for structured advocacy.
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ❌ |
| Warrant Requirement | ❌ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ✅ |
| Family Communication | ❌ |
→
Next step: Add a warrant requirement + simple public statement + parent communication
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ❌ |
| Warrant Requirement | ❌ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ⚠️ |
| Family Communication | ⚠️ |
→
Next step: Start with a warrant requirement + basic policy + reassurance to families
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ❌ |
| Warrant Requirement | ❌ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ⚠️ |
| Family Communication | ⚠️ |
→
Next step: Create a basic public policy with a warrant requirement
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ❌ |
| Warrant Requirement | ❌ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ⚠️ |
| Family Communication | ❌ |
→
Next step: Add warrant requirement + one-page policy + staff guidance
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ❌ |
| Warrant Requirement | ❌ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ⚠️ |
| Family Communication | ❌ |
→
Next step: Start with a warrant requirement + public-facing communication
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ❌ |
| Warrant Requirement | ❌ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ⚠️ |
| Family Communication | ⚠️ |
→
Next step: Add a warrant requirement + clear public policy
Most Utah districts are starting from zero.
That is not a reason for despair — it is an opportunity. A school board that has
never considered a warrant policy hasn't rejected it. The ask is to create something
new, not to reverse an existing position.
The largest district in Utah — Alpine — has no public protective policy. It serves
over 90,000 students. That is the single highest-impact organizing target in the state.
❌
Tier 3 — Minimal or No Public Protections
Most Utah districts fall here, including Alpine — the largest district in the state. All share essentially the same baseline: nothing formally in place.
| Protection | Status |
| Public Policy | ❌ |
| Warrant Requirement | ❌ |
| Front Office Protocol | ❌ |
| Student Privacy | ⚠️ |
| Family Communication | ❌ |
→
Next step: Adopt a warrant requirement + written policy + front office protocol
★
Alpine School District priority: Alpine is the largest school district in Utah and among the 50 largest in the country, serving over 90,000 students. A policy adoption here would be transformative. It is the single highest-impact organizing target in the state.